Torchweek

[strange_complex]

Well, I really think that was one of the best things I have ever seen on television. The twists, the turns, the tension, the emotional impact. Every single person in it was brilliant, every character fully fleshed out, every development of the plot meaningful and logical. Seriously - WOW. I am genuinely sorry that I will never be able to have the experience of watching it fresh, and gasping and squealing with each new discovery, ever again.

The one worry tonight was that RTD would bring out the Total Bollocks Overdrive. Yes, the solution was arrived at surprisingly rapidly, and it was also extremely neat, as it rather has to be if the conventions of the Whoniverse (viz, that at the end of the story it could still conceivably be our universe) are to be left intact. But the Earth wasn't dragged halfway across the universe; gruelling experiences which the characters had been through were not totally wiped out; there was no deus ex machina, no magic fairy dust and no need to resort to a parallel universe in order to have things both ways. In short, someone was obviously exercising a restraining hand on the greater excesses of Rusty's imagination - and good for them.

The only other thing I'll pause to note is how much Jack's decision about Steven (his grandson) reminded me of Agamemnon's decision about Iphigeneia in the mythology of the Trojan War (and especially Euripides' Iphigeneia at Aulis. Agamemnon must choose between public duty and private affection when the gods ask him to sacrifice his daughter, Iphigeneia, in order to placate Artemis and allow the Greek army to set sail on their war against Troy. Jack doesn't take long to make the decision once it is forced upon him, but the same agony is clearly there, and I found it extremely compelling.

As for the future - the door is still open, I suppose, at the very least for Jack to turn up on Doctor Who at some time. Given the enormous success this mini-series has had in terms of audience ratings, there have got to be pressures in favour of a repeat. But tonight felt to me a very great deal like a final act of closure. And although I'm sad about that - WHAT a closure.

Click here to view this entry with minimal formatting.

Comments

[ladyguinevere83.livejournal.com]

Overall, I really enjoyed the series. I loved it being a five-parter; it was like a return to the old Doctor Who serials, which is something I've been wanting for DW for a while. I love multi-episode arcs.

Throughout it, particularly after Ianto died, I was expecting there to be a reset button of some kind, or some hitherto unknown way out of it, but I was kind of glad there wasn't. The last episode was dark in a way that I hadn't expected, and though it gives me a perculiar feeling, I'm glad they did that.

Jack has a lot of redemption to go to make up for it though, a lot of soul searching to do before he can come to terms with it. If they bring him back in either series without addressing that, I will be mightily annoyed.

[rosaguestlist.livejournal.com]

Yes, I thought it was like having the old style of Doctor Who story back, rather than the current ADD generation approach. I also liked the fact that virtually no special effects were really required - this script could easily have been filmed fifty years ago (bar some of the content). Using the smoke filled chamber relied on suggestion to an extent that I didn't think anyone would ever do anymore.

I thought Capaldi's was probably the best piece of acting since Doctor Who returned.

- K

[strange-complex.livejournal.com]

Yes, that's a good point about the use of suggestion. I certainly noticed it and was impressed by it, but hadn't got as far as thinking how unusual it is these days - more's the pity.

And indeed - Capaldi was absolutely masterful.