New Who 4.6, The Doctor's Daughter

[strange_complex]

Given that I'd expected this episode to be abysmally bad, I'm glad to say I was able to be pleasantly surprised when it in fact turned out to be merely pretty lame.

It had some corking concepts, after all. I loved the idea of the rapid overturn of generations turning a week into the social equivalent of several centuries. It seems very apt in a show that's about time travel, and it brought up all sorts of interesting ideas about what it is that really constitutes a society's identity - its genetic code, or its history and values? If the latter are lost, what have you really got? Nothing much but a pointless war, according to this episode.

And obviously the same nature vs. nurture issue was central to the character of Jenny, too - was she a Time Lord or not, if she only had the Doctor's DNA and not the shared history and shared suffering which he claims had held the Time Lords together? (Much like Classical myths of shared origins, I note). The answer this time seems to have been different, though - or at least, the Doctor made it different over the course of the episode, by showing Jenny enough of what being a Time Lord could mean to give her the beginnings of the nurture she was missing.

And the fatherhood stuff in general wasn't half bad, either. The way it was so sudden and arbitrary and involuntary - just like it often is - but turned out to mean something all the same. There were actually some pretty profound points about the nature of family bonds lurking under there.

Then there were the little things, too. Like the human colonists' main base being a theatre - because meta is always good. And underground corridors for the Classic win! And fish with reverse scuba gear!

So what went so wrong? Part of it was the script, I think - the Doctor in particular seemed to get a lot of lines that were actually just very pedestrian plot-exposition, and nobody really got much in the way of sparkle or humour. It also didn't do Martha any favours to be placed alongside Donna in such a closed setting. I really liked Martha in the previous series, but she suddenly looks awfully thin and weedy (I mean as a character, not physically, though that is arguably also true) next to Donna.

Then there was predictability - like Jenny's (temporary) death becoming utterly inevitable the minute she said she wanted to see new worlds. Astrid in Voyage of the Damned was too recent for that to be any fun, and although you could argue that the trope was subverted by the fact that she then came back to life afterwards, it wasn't a clever enough subversion, and I didn't much like the idea of her resurrection anyway. Partly that's just because I didn't particularly warm to her character and have no interest in seeing her in the series ever again - except that now we are clearly saddled with her. Partly it's because I don't like to see death being presented as negotiable in any genre. And partly because it didn't make story-sense for her not to have regenerated in the ordinary Time Lord fashion.

I suppose we're meant to imagine that, since she's only recently been created, she's still within the same grace period that allowed the Doctor to regenerate his hand in The Christmas Invasion - especially since so much emphasis was placed on the hand itself at the beginning and end of the episode. But it seems convoluted to do it that way, when a proper regeneration would have reinforced the idea that she really was a Time Lord after all (and given her an experience in common with the Doctor). I know perfectly well why, in production terms, this wasn't done - it wouldn't have allowed for a time-delay during which the Doctor could leave the planet believing her to be dead, and it would also have meant discarding an actress they were clearly pleased to have got on board, and confusing audiences when she (inevitably) reappears in the finale. But that doesn't change the fact that in story terms, a normal regeneration would have been much more satisfying.

Still, it's over, and we can get on with looking ahead to the rest of the series. The next three episodes have every reason to be fabulous, and then we're into RTD-scripted territory for the run-up to the finale. So what new clues has this episode given us for the end of the season?

1. Jenny will very obviously be back in the finale. New Who doesn't redefine the parameters of the Whoniverse mid-season and then forget about it.
2. If one Jenny can be created from the Doctor so easily, so can legions more. This episode seems to have danced rather ambiguously around the question of what recreating the Time Lords in this way would mean - they would lack the knowledge and history that defined Time Lord society, but apparently could be brought up to speed via a few quick lessons from the Doctor anyway. I don't really want to see them brought back on these terms myself, and am not sure even RTD does either. But the possibility has been established.
3. Donna wants to travel with the Doctor forever? Oh dear, because I really, really like her - and saying that is (obviously) a death-warrant.
4. It may seem like a small thing - but a 'New Byzantine' calendar? It stood out to me because of the Classical relevance, but a bit of Googling also told me that no 'New Byzantine' society has ever been mentioned in Doctor Who before. So if it's not a continuity reference, is it a clue? Will be interesting to see.

Anyway, for the moment, I am off to watch Horror of Fang Rock. Because I can!

Comments

[strange-complex.livejournal.com]

perhaps Jenny chose to keep the same form

She didn't seem in much of a position to make choices about what she looked like to me. I agree that there was some similarity with Seven's regeneration into Eight - but he did change form.

[paulgregory.livejournal.com]

Perhaps a side-effect of the nature of Jenny's creation is that all her regenerations are identical clones?

But as for "it would also have meant discarding an actress they were clearly pleased to have got on board" - having seen (half of) Confidential, they could have had her regenerate into a redhead and kept the same actress.

Anyway. I agree that she's fairly obviously returning in the finale, and I'd put money on this being more obvious once we get the title for 4x12.

[strange-complex.livejournal.com]

I like the side-effect idea - although like any of the possibilities, it'll need further on-screen discussion to resolve the issue. And true about the red hair! I think she looked a lot nicer with it than the blonde pony-tail, actually.