strange_complex: (One walking)
[personal profile] strange_complex
I think we can chalk that up as another cracker. I don't have time to write much about it, as I'm going to Romania tomorrow and need to prioritise prepping for that, but a few thoughts.

God, I love stories about a small band of people trapped in an adverse situation. I believe I have mentioned this before - e.g. it's why one of my favourite early Classic Who stories is The Edge of Destruction. They are so good for character development, and just as The Edge of Destruction really helped to seal the main characters for the Hartnell era, so also this was a very good choice of format when we were getting to know a new (and by recent standards unusually large) TARDIS team. There's still more development to go, but we have moved forward with them. I think I still love Graham the most - probably largely because the other two are (sadly!) a bit too young for me to relate to these days. He did something particular which really made me *heart* him part-way through this episode, but I already can't remember what. Feel free to write suggestions as to what I might have like in the comments!

Angstrom's response to his comment that the Stenza had killed his wife - can't remember the exact words but something like "Mine too" - gave us the first explicit moment of queer representation under the new regime. Good - I'm pleased that that is still in place.

That first location they found for the ruins - the crumbling concrete with the green paint - was absolutely spectacular. Judging from the opening credits, it was somewhere in South Africa, which speaks of a commitment to high production values.

The whole thing felt gritty, serious, and sometimes outright scary - and in my book those are good things. Angstrom's references to her world being cleansed, and both her and Epzo's willingness to undergo huge hardship and almost certain death in order to win a better life for their families (in her case at least - I think his motivation was more self-centred), both felt like parallels for the desperation of real-world refugees from war and persecution, and I'm pleased again that the new regime continues to see it as part of Doctor Who's role to raise and explore these issues.

The burnt-edged papery, fabricy, snakey things (according to Wikipedia they were called the Remnants) were quite M.R. Jamesish! And I liked how the set-up for defeating them worked through, from what seemed initially like the Doctor just finding a way to help Ryan find the courage and focus he needed to climb the ladder, to a scientific solution which he had contributed to. Though I'm not sure I fully understand why they didn't just attack everyone straight away, and although I probably didn't catch it fully, I didn't much like the sound of prophetic stuff about a 'Timeless Child' either. That's exactly the sort of thing I was pleased not to be hearing last week. :-/

Finally, the new TARDIS interior genuinely was awesome, and I'm glad I saw that completely unspoiled. Hexagons, circles, an organic crystalline feel, and custard creams to boot! Judging from next week's setting, though, it looks like her time and space calibration is a bit off-kilter. It could take a while before the Doctor can get her chums back to where and when they actually came from. :-)

Date: Sunday, 14 October 2018 19:29 (UTC)
rmc28: Rachel smiling against background of trees, with newly-cut short hair (Default)
From: [personal profile] rmc28
The 12yo watching with me said "this show is quite good at feeling scary" :-)

Date: Sunday, 14 October 2018 19:47 (UTC)
hollymath: Selfie: white person, three-quarter profile, smiling, brown hair shaved on the side we can see, chin-length on the other (Default)
From: [personal profile] hollymath
I thought of M.R. James too at that bit. :)

I think I agree with everything you said here except that I don't much like Graham but he was a lot better this week. I like Ryan and I want to see more of Yaz. Judging from the trailer, she seemed excited about Rosa Parks and I hope that is developed a bit.

Patrick Troughton on line one

Date: Sunday, 14 October 2018 21:47 (UTC)
qatsi: (baker)
From: [personal profile] qatsi
I thought this was ... OK. I'm still finding the incidental music intrusive, and I'm not liking the amount of darkness, which just makes it difficult to see what's going on. I didn't like the darkness of the TARDIS interior at all - I preferred the Smith/Capaldi interiors, or even (gasp) the classic model.

I do like Graham - he's reminding me quite a bit of Ian - he thinks he should be in charge, but at the same time sees he's way out of his depth. (There was some line to that effect, I wonder if that's what you are thinking of).

Date: Monday, 15 October 2018 00:48 (UTC)
sir_guinglain: (Jodie)
From: [personal profile] sir_guinglain
I somehow find this 'Timeless Child' more interesting than mentions of a 'Hybrid'. There's something more identifiable about it. As I've said elsewhere, I've enjoyed the political critique I think Chibnall is writing. Angstrom's motives are more co-operative than Epzo's; and I hadn't thought of the Remnants in Jamesian terms but you are right. (Another parallel offered, by [ profile] purserhallard is of the snakes in a game of snakes and ladders.)


strange_complex: (Default)

February 2019

456789 10


Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Tuesday, 26 March 2019 08:52
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios