strange_complex: (Metropolis False Maria)
[personal profile] strange_complex
I'll admit my heart sank for a moment as I realised this was going to be another story about a big corporation. I expected something similar to Arachnids in the UK, which had probably been my least favourite episode so far this season, and wasn't relishing a repeat of its pretty unsubtle message about corporate greed. In fact, though, this was a much more interesting story, with a nuanced perspective on automation that I genuinely didn't expect.

Actually, between the references to the 'People Power' protest movement, the fact that people kept disappearing and the power-drains, for a long time I was expecting to find that the plant was somehow powering itself by devouring its own workers - literal 'people power'. But no - far from it. Instead we met a benign system run by well-meaning people who had detected problems but didn't know how to solve them, and which had therefore sought out external help against the real problem, a misguided human being. The crux of it all came in the Doctor's attempt to talk Charlie (that human being) round, when she told him that the problem was not the system itself, but how people - including him - use and exploit it.

Rather as with last week's Thijar, this ran contrary to established Whovian genre expectations. We've seen a lot of killer robots (and cyborgs) over the years, which helped to make the twist inversion of the trope surprising. I think I liked it, and have a lot of sympathy for the view that technology isn't inherently good or bad itself but a tool which can be turned to either purpose. There's also certainly room for criticising people like Charlie who see an ideological cause as more important than individual lives.

He seemed like rather an exaggerated straw-man representative of that position, though, and I could have done with understanding more of the wider context in order to feel entirely at ease with the morality of it all. As in previous stories - most notably The Ghost Monument - passing references suggested a pretty harsh socio-economic context. The workers at Kerblam! are grateful for even the most menial jobs, since so many people in this galaxy don't have any - a situation explicitly attributed to the rise of technology. Kira never knew her parents, has only ever received one tiny present (from her boss) and has never had anything nice said about her.

The suggested picture is bleak, but it would have been helpful to know more about the People Power Protest Movement which has already led to Kerblam! employing a mandatory 10% of organic workers, what else had led Charlie to the ideological position he'd arrived at, and how exactly his plan of killing thousands of Kerblam's customers was supposed to help. I got the impression we were supposed to have some sympathy for his position, recognising it as valid but simply Gone Too Far - especially since we discovered in the coda to the story that his aim was basically going to be realised in the company's new policy of employing a majority of organic workers. But as I've said above, I felt he came across as too much a stereotype of ideological fervour for that to work properly. I'll be interested to see what other viewers made of it once I've finished writing this.

Meanwhile, back with our regular characters, we learnt a fair bit about Ryan's previous experiences of employment in a similar company back in the People's Republic of South Yorkshire, including how his mates covered for his dyspraxia-induced struggles when he started - and it was nice to see, just as Andrew Hickey noted in relation to the very first episode of this series that his dyspraxia hasn't gone away, but is merely something he is gradually discovering he can take on and work around. Yaz's insistence on taking Dan's necklace back to his daughter also tells us that she has very much taken on board what she learnt about family, and the little artefacts which represent them, in last week's story.

Finally, I chuckled at the comment on past Doctor Who monsters implicit in making literal bubble-wrap the deadly threat of the week. And was it me, or did the Doctor do Venusian aikido on Jarva Slade?

Looking forward to some folk horror next week! :-)

Date: Monday, 19 November 2018 07:52 (UTC)
djm4: (Default)
From: [personal profile] djm4
I thought Charlie's actions, and what happened to him, brought an otherwise interesting episode right down. Fundamentally, in today's political climate, I'm not sure I'm ready for the message 'big business is benign, and the left are violent and bad in the same way as the right', and we didn't know enough about the rest of the economic system that Kermblam! operates in to see it as anything other than that.

Why the 10% organic rule - is that supposed to be a good thing? It's presented as though Kermblam! *could* be fully automated if it was allowed to be, and it didn't look as though the jobs on offer were especially fulfilling, so I'd have liked to see more discussion of the background to that. It's a complex question, and it wasn't presented as such.

And then, the Doctor murders Charlie.

There was no apparent need for her to detonate the bubble wrap there and then, so why did she? It was an extra order, over and above the recall of the delivery bots, so it wasn't just an inevitable but unfortunate side effect of her actions. If Charlie had at that point been shown to be setting a manual override on the bots, that might have explained both the need for urgency and his murder, but there was no hint of that.

I saw someone on Twitter saying that this felt like The Sunmakers. No. This is The Sunmakers if The Doctor gasses all the rebels to stop them throwing Gatherer Hadd off the roof, and then leaves with assurances from The Collector and Hade that they're going to tax everyone a bit less in future.

Date: Monday, 19 November 2018 10:53 (UTC)
danieldwilliam: (Default)
From: [personal profile] danieldwilliam
I quite liked it.

I was a bit distracted whilst watching it because I was doing the washing up so My Lovely Wife could be Mrs Pockets.

I was pleased to see some this season do some socio-economic science fiction. The first handful of episodes were fairly straightforward running around playing tag with some sort of outside menace. This one (and the last one) were more thought provoking.

I'm a bit puzzled as to who is buying anything from Kerblam if only 10% of the population have jobs but I'm not sure the lump of labour fallacy is really prime time family entertainment.

Date: Monday, 19 November 2018 12:03 (UTC)
sfred: (Default)
From: [personal profile] sfred
I was basically enjoying it, liking the twists and the unusual perspectives, and then the Doctor killed someone and I was thrown right out of it.

Date: Friday, 23 November 2018 17:41 (UTC)
amaebi: black fox (Default)
From: [personal profile] amaebi
Looking forward to experiencing this episode!

Profile

strange_complex: (Default)
strange_complex

February 2019

M T W T F S S
    123
456789 10
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728   

Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Tuesday, 26 March 2019 08:37
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios